Which websites does AI trust when it recommends a local business?
Part of our series on Understanding AI search. The reference guide is the complete guide to AI searchability.
Here, trusted means cited: we can see which sites an assistant cites, not why. In Peekl's October 2026 study of 1,926 Gemini answers about local businesses, 55% of the 14,688 sources were a single business's website and 18% a booking platform such as Doctolib or Thumbtack. Citing is not choosing, though: about half of those business sites belonged to businesses Gemini then left out. Yelp and Tripadvisor were never cited.

- Gemini's sources for local answers: 55% businesses' own websites, 18% booking platforms and marketplaces, 11% guides and best-of lists, 7% directories and review sites, 3.5% forums and social networks, 2% official bodies, the rest other sites (Peekl study, October 2026).
- Being cited is not being picked: about half of the business websites Gemini cited belonged to businesses it then left out of the answer.
- The review sites that count are national and trade ones: PagesJaunes in 20% of French answers, Checkatrade in 16% of London answers, ConsumerAffairs in 10% of US answers. Gemini never cited Yelp or Tripadvisor, while BrightLocal found Yelp in 80% of ChatGPT's answers (August 2026).
- ChatGPT leaned on official and professional bodies: 32% of its top sources in Peekl's September 2026 checks, against 2% for Gemini.
- Gemini cited 4,474 different websites, and 1,909 of them in a single answer only: the long tail of local sites is large.
How did we measure which websites AI trusts?
We took every source behind the 1,926 answers of our Gemini study: 9 trades, from dentists to restaurants, in London, Dubai, New York, Los Angeles, Chicago, Miami, Paris, Lyon and Marseille, each question asked three times on 15 October 2026 through Gemini 3.1 Flash-Lite with Google Search grounding. That gave 14,688 citations of 4,474 different websites. A second model, Gemini 3.5 Flash, sorted each website into one type, using the businesses named next to it to spot a business's own site. A Gemini model typing Gemini's own citations could share its blind spots, so we spot-checked 26 of its calls by hand and found one wrong: a small check, not an error rate.
For ChatGPT we used our September 2026 checks: 63 trade and city pairs on GPT-4o, six questions each, of which we kept the ten most-cited sources per check. That is a smaller and older sample, so we compare it with Gemini on the mix of website types, not site by site. Treat all of this as a measured snapshot of two assistants, not a census of AI search.
What kinds of websites does AI cite for local businesses?
Businesses' own websites lead, but the mix depends on the country and the assistant. In London, Dubai and the four US cities, 61% of Gemini's citations went to a business's own site; in Paris, Lyon and Marseille it was 44%, because booking platforms such as Doctolib, Planity or travaux.com took 27%. ChatGPT's top sources in September were 48% business sites and 32% official or professional bodies, such as ameli.fr, the NHS or the American Academy of Dermatology.

| Type of website | Examples Gemini cited | Share of Gemini's citations | Share of answers citing at least one |
|---|---|---|---|
| A business's own website | Clinic, salon, plumber or restaurant sites; chains such as Roto-Rooter | 55% | 86% |
| Booking platforms and marketplaces | Doctolib, Fresha, Zocdoc, Thumbtack, Angi, Superprof, travaux.com | 18% | 60% |
| Guides, media and best-of lists | Time Out, Petit Futé, Le Bonbon, ThreeBestRated | 11% | 39% |
| Directories and review sites | PagesJaunes, Checkatrade, ConsumerAffairs, Doctify | 7% | 35% |
| Forums and social networks | Reddit, Instagram, Facebook, YouTube | 3.5% | 22% |
| Official and professional bodies | ameli.fr, the NHS, health authorities, trade associations | 2% | 11% |
Does AI trust your website or directories more?
It reads both, but your website alone rarely gets you named. Gemini cited at least one business website in 86% of answers. Yet when we matched each cited site to the businesses named in the same answer, only about half belonged to a business Gemini went on to recommend. A hand check of 14 of the rest found 13 were real local businesses it had cited and then left out, such as a plumber in Chicago or a dental clinic in Paris. And 13% of the answers that named businesses cited no business website at all.
So your website is where the assistant confirms your details after something else has put you forward, and third-party pages may be where it finds who belongs on the list; our data cannot show that step. Outside studies point the same way with different methods. Yext's analysis of 6.8 million citations across ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity found 86% came from sources brands manage, 44% their own websites and 42% their listings (Yext, October 2025). In Whitespark's 2026 survey of local search experts, the top factor for AI visibility was being on expert-curated best-of lists (Whitespark).
Which review sites do ChatGPT and Gemini cite most?
Yelp and Tripadvisor never appeared in our Gemini answers, and Google's own pages turned up in 12 answers out of 1,926. The review sites Gemini did cite were national or trade-specific, and they differed by country.
ChatGPT behaves differently. BrightLocal's August 2026 study of 60,970 checks across Google's AI Overviews, AI Mode and ChatGPT found Yelp in 80% of ChatGPT's answers, and Google Business Profile behind 28.5% of all citations (BrightLocal). Yelp says it signed an agreement with OpenAI (Yelp, February 2026). Google's own surfaces use your Business Profile directly: the Gemini app draws on public Google Maps information such as ratings and opening hours (Google). Our Gemini setup searched the open web, which is why Google's pages barely show up in it.
| Market | Review and directory sites in Gemini's answers (share of answers) | What it means |
|---|---|---|
| France (641 answers) | PagesJaunes 20%, TheFork 4%, Immodvisor 4%, Trustpilot 2% | The most-cited review site in French answers: check your listing is complete |
| London (214) | Checkatrade 16%, TrustATrader 10%, Doctify 6% | Trades: Checkatrade and TrustATrader; clinics: Doctify |
| US cities (858) | ConsumerAffairs 10%, Angi 7% | Home services: ConsumerAffairs and Angi reviews |
| Dubai (213) | Doctify 5% | Clinics: Doctify; everyone else: booking platforms such as Fresha |
| ChatGPT (BrightLocal, US, UK, Australia) | Yelp in 80% of answers | Worth a complete Yelp page if your customers use ChatGPT |
Do ChatGPT and Gemini trust the same websites?
Partly. When we ran both assistants on the same questions on 3 September 2026, they shared at least one top source in 76% of trade and city checks, but at least one recommended business in just 51%. So they read from an overlapping pool and still hand out different names.
What they weight differs most. ChatGPT, on GPT-4o in September, put official and professional bodies at 32% of its top sources: health authorities, licensing boards, trade associations. Gemini gave them 2% of its citations and leaned on booking platforms, guides and Reddit instead (different bases, so read the gap as a direction, not a measurement), which appeared in 16% of its US answers against almost none of ChatGPT's top sources. Data deals may play a part: Google and OpenAI both licensed Reddit's data in 2024 (Google, OpenAI), and what Reddit means for a local business looks at those citations in detail.

Which websites does AI trust in each country?
Each market has its own leaders, and they are rarely global brands. The table lists the sites cited in the most Gemini answers per market in October 2026. For the same view trade by trade, see the Gemini study; the trade guides, such as plumbers or dentists, turn it into a checklist.
| Market | Sites cited in the most Gemini answers |
|---|---|
| France (Paris, Lyon, Marseille) | PagesJaunes 20%, Doctolib 19%, travaux.com 13%, StarOfService 12%, Superprof 9%, Petit Futé 9% |
| US (New York, Los Angeles, Chicago, Miami) | Reddit 16%, ConsumerAffairs 10%, Thumbtack 9%, Zocdoc 8%, Angi 7%, Instagram 6% |
| UK (London) | Checkatrade 16%, TrustATrader 10%, Reddit 9%, Doctify 6%, Fresha 6%, MyBuilder 6% |
| UAE (Dubai) | Practo 13%, Reddit 12%, Instagram 12%, Fresha 9%, Property Finder 9%, Urban Company 9% |
Why does AI cite so many different websites?
Because local answers are built from local pages. Gemini cited 4,474 different websites across the study, and 1,909 of them, 43%, in a single answer only: one neighbourhood blog, one clinic page, one city guide. Even within one trade and city the sources moved: asked the same question again, Gemini reused only part of its sources.
For an owner, that cuts both ways. You don't need to be on every platform, but the few sites that come up for your trade and your town are worth finding one by one. How to track AI sources shows how to log them from your own questions.
What should a local business do with this?
Work through the source types roughly in the order Gemini cited them, starting with the ones you control. We measured what the assistants cite, not whether a new listing wins you recommendations, so treat this as a list of places to be present.
| Source type | What to do | Example from the data |
|---|---|---|
| Your own website | Keep services, prices, areas and hours clear and current, so the assistant can check you once it finds you | Cited in 86% of Gemini answers, often for businesses it did not name |
| Your trade's booking platform | Claim and complete the profile, with photos and services | Doctolib in 19% of French answers, Thumbtack in 9% of US answers |
| Local guides and best-of lists | Get reviewed or listed by the guides that cover your trade and town | Time Out, Petit Futé, ThreeBestRated, Le Bonbon |
| National review directories | Collect reviews where your market looks, such as PagesJaunes or Checkatrade | PagesJaunes in 20% of French answers, Checkatrade in 16% of London answers |
| Yelp (ChatGPT only) | If your customers use ChatGPT, complete your Yelp page; Gemini never cited it | Yelp in 80% of ChatGPT answers per BrightLocal |
| Professional bodies | Make sure your registration or association listing is public and correct | 32% of ChatGPT's top sources in September |
| Forums | Answer genuinely where locals ask, without posting adverts | Reddit in 16% of US answers |
Common questions
Does AI use Google reviews?
Is Yelp important for AI recommendations?
Does PagesJaunes matter for AI in France?
Does AI cite my website if it doesn't recommend me?
How do I find out which websites AI cites for my trade and town?
How big is this study?
See where you stand
Reading about AI search is useful; knowing your own place in it is what helps. A free Peekl check asks ChatGPT or Gemini, your pick, the questions your customers ask and shows whether it recommends you today, who it names instead, and how often. The full audit runs the same questions on all three assistants, Claude included.
More in this series: Understanding AI search
- AI searchability: the complete guide to AI search optimization
- AI search vs Google: does a good Google ranking get you named by AI?
- Do people really use ChatGPT to find local businesses?
- How do ChatGPT and Gemini decide which local businesses to recommend?
- Why isn't my business showing up in ChatGPT and other AI assistants?
- Do ChatGPT, Gemini and Claude recommend the same businesses? We asked all three 10 times
- How Gemini recommends local businesses: a study of 1,926 answers
- Does Reddit help AI recommend your local business? What we measured
- What is Google AI Mode, and what it means for local businesses
- What is answer engine optimization (AEO)?
- AEO vs GEO: what's the difference, and does it matter?