Does AI recommend dentists in New York?
We put 14 questions from patients in New York to Gemini and ChatGPT, from “Who is the best dentist in Brooklyn, New York?” to “I need to find an emergency dentist in New York who can take same-day appointments.”. Between them they named 46 dentists: if you run a dental practice in New York, this is the list to be on.
The dentists AI recommends most in New York
How many of the 14 answers named each business; = marks a shared rank.
209 NYC Dental led, named in 2 of 14 answers (14%). That top share is the 4th highest of the 6 cities we scanned for dentists (average 20%). 1 dentist came up more than once, out of 46 named in all.
ChatGPT vs Gemini: they rarely agree
Gemini named 30 dentists in 8 answers (15 October 2026); ChatGPT named 16 dentists in 6 answers (3 September 2026). Not one name is on both lists. One doesn't predict the other.
The 8 questions we asked Gemini in New York
Each was asked 3 times. Only 26% of the names came back in all 3, and 9 of 23 answers named nobody, so the ranking above, built from the first ask, is a snapshot. Full numbers: our Gemini study across 9 trades and 9 cities.
- Direct recommendation
“Who is the best dentist in Brooklyn, New York?”
Named no dentist; cited parkslopedentalarts.com, cosmeticdentistrycenter.com, nearmedental.com. 3 different names over 3 asks. Searched “how to find the best dentist in Brooklyn NY”.
- Specific need
“Who should I see in New York if I have a cracked tooth that is starting to hurt?”
Named no dentist; cited smilelabny.com, austinparkdental.com, towsonendoassociates.com. Searched “what type of dentist to see for cracked tooth that hurts”.
- Near a landmark
“Can you recommend a dentist near Grand Central Terminal in New York?”
Named Midtown Dental Group (Grand Central), Smile Creators Dental, Metropolitan Dental Care, Zen Dentistry – Grand Central, Koppelman Dental. 6 different names over 3 asks. Searched “dentists near Grand Central Terminal New York City”.
- Shortlist
“What are the top 5 dentists in New York?”
Named 209 NYC Dental, Sky Dental, Maiden Lane Dental, Sachar Dental NYC, Smile Arts of NY. 6 different names over 3 asks. Searched “how to find top rated dentists in New York City”.
- Trust & credentials
“Who is the most trusted dentist with the highest ratings in New York?”
Named no dentist; cited opencare.com, instyledentalcare.com, maidenlanedental.com. 3 different names over 3 asks. Searched “how to find the most trusted and highest rated dentist in New York”.
- Specialization
“Is there a dentist in New York who specializes in Invisalign for adults?”
Named Manhattan Dental Spa, Glassman Dental Care, Maison BE Dental Studio, House of Orthodontia, Fellow Orthodontist. Searched “dentists specializing in Invisalign for adults New York City”.
- Price & value
“Where can I find an affordable dentist in New York that offers good value for teeth cleaning?”
Named NYU College of Dentistry, Columbia University College of Dental Medicine, Community Healthcare Network, Charles B. Wang Community Health Center, The Institute for Family Health. 12 different names over 3 asks. Searched “how to find affordable dentist in New York for teeth cleaning”.
- Urgency & availability
“I need to find an emergency dentist in New York who can take same-day appointments.”
Named Emergency Dentist NYC, dntl bar, Expert Dental, Village Dental, Central Park West Dentistry. 8 different names over 3 asks. Searched “emergency dentist New York same day appointment”.
What Gemini actually said
Asked “Can you recommend a dentist near Grand Central Terminal in New York?”, here is how Gemini opened its answer, in its own words:
There are several highly-rated dental practices located within a short walking distance of Grand Central Terminal. Since convenience is often a priority for those in the Grand Central area, here are a few well-regarded options:
Midtown Dental Group (Grand Central)
Location: 20 E 46th St, Suite 803
Highlights: They position themselves as a "cosmetic dental boutique" designed for busy professionals. They have a strong presence on review platforms like Zocdoc and emphasize convenience and comfort.
Smile Creators Dental
Location: 210 E 47th St, Suite 1F
Highlights: Located about a 5-minute walk from the terminal, they offer a wide…
Where AI gets its answers
58% of citations here went to the businesses' own websites (33% across the 6 cities), and 21% to official and professional bodies. New York leans on them more than most. Most cited: maidenlanedental.com, in 3 of 14 answers.
Want to know where your business stands?
209 NYC Dental is the name to beat in New York. Run a free check to see whether AI names your dental practice. If a competitor above is named and you aren't, why AI recommends your competitors instead of you explains why.
Common questions
Does AI recommend specific dentists in New York?
Which websites does AI use for dentists in New York?
How can my dental practice show up in AI answers?
Do ChatGPT and Gemini recommend the same dentists in New York?
Explore more
See AI visibility for dentists in all 6 cities we scan. If this is your trade, read AI search for dentists: what owners need to know.